Differences in Caseloads. First, these metrics can be highly contextual as they can be impacted by prosecutors and other governmental parties involved in cases, as well as the priorities, decisions, and available resources within a given jurisdiction. 4 0 obj We also analyzed data reported by counties to the State Controllers Office and the California Department of Justice. This is because these groups are more likely to be (1)involved with Californias criminal justice system due to the racial disparities that currently exist in the system and (2)lowerincome due to economic disparities that have existed historically. Specifically, in a 2016 report examining the Los Angeles area, the Federal Reserve Bank of San Franciscoin partnership with several universities and research organizationsfound that the median net worth of U.S. African American households ($4,000), Mexican households ($3,500), and other Latino households ($42,500) were substantially lower than white households ($355,000). Jurisdictions may differ in how they interpret, implement, and determine whether the standards have been met. <> Additionally, the 202122 budget included $50million annually for three years for indigent defense providers to address certain postconviction proceedings. 15 0 obj In a slightly different approach, one California indigent defense provider has chosen to evaluate the quality of their services by surveying criminal justice stakeholderssuch as judges and other criminal defense attorneysto obtain their perspectives on how effectively their attorneys are representing their clients. <>/Font<>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> This report presents the results of the first national study of access to counsel in U.S. immigration courts. For example, sufficient resources can enable indigent defense providers to spend the time necessary to develop a trusting relationship with their clients in order to obtain information that can be critical to a defense, to assess what outcomes are desired (such as to minimize time spent incarcerated or to avoid immigration consequences), and to assist clients to determine how they would like to proceed in their cases. For example, certain city attorneys within Los Angeles County generally prosecute misdemeanors and funding for these offices are not captured in the data below. Additionally, we exclude Shasta County since it does not appear any data was reported during this time period.) State Public Defender submits this report on the review of our internal control and monitoring systems for the biennial period ending December 31, 2021. The Office of State Public Defender (OSPD) was established in 2011 to continue the work of Capital Defense (est. stream Such statewide reporting is critical to ensure the state has the necessary information to conduct oversight of how effectively indigent defense services are provided across the state. However, as we discuss below, the lack of consistent data and metrics makes it difficult to fully evaluate existing service levels at this time. Challenges Collecting Data. (Aswediscuss below, the state recently authorized the Office of the State Public Defender [OSPD] to assist trial court indigent defense providers.). 989-739-3211 Ext. endobj <> Application For Appointment Of Counsel. The budget also required counties to report on how the funding was used and that an independent evaluation be conducted to assess the impact of the provided funding by August 1, 2025. As shown in Figure8, spending per arrest in 201819 varies across counties, with greater variance in per arrest spending on district attorney offices as compared to indigent defense. ) UAhX]#?C|K V9ovh5(u{y6,c(dMaK%{+@Kfe*? Accordingly, the total resources available for prosecution are likely greater than reflected in the available data. Federal law and local court rules govern the procedure for implementing the right to counsel. Alternatively, the Legislature could contract with external researchers to help establish specific outcome and performance measures. As such, this data reflects a trend to inform theLegislature. endobj 2007) and Training (est. Data describing A State Plan is an OSHA-approved safety and health program that enforces its own occupational safety and health standards which are required to be at least as effective as federal OSHA's, but may have different or additional requirements. We further recommend that the metrics reflect the states definition of what constitutes effective legal assistance as well as expectations for meeting those goals. These metrics can also be used for comparisons within offices, across jurisdictions, or over time. 2007) and Training (est. As discussed above, the U.S. and California Constitutions guarantee the right to effective attorney assistance (unless knowingly and intelligently waived) to ensure that defendants in criminal proceedings receive equal protection under law and due process before being deprived of life or liberty. There are also challenges coordinating data collection from private law firms or attorneys providing indigent defense. Currently, only the Chief Public Defender of San Francisco County is elected. endobj In more recent years, various jurisdictions have used weighted. Efficiency Metrics. See 636(b)(1); McCarthy v. Bronson, 500 U.S. 136 (1991). OSPD - Office of State Public Defender 1 2 3 4 5 6 Welcome The California Legislature created the Office of the State Public Defender in 1976 to represent indigent criminal defendants on appeal. This is because a defendant might not feel their case was fairly and fully argued. Section 2A: Verification of claim of indigency; waiver by claimant allowing access to information; reassessments following appointment of counsel; reporting Section 2A. This means that the magnitude of the difference in staffing levels between public defender and district attorney offices can be much greater in certain counties. Alleged Ways Fresno County Failed to Provide Effective Indigent Criminal Defense Service Levels. JFIF ` ` C As a result, counties have taken different approaches to evaluating and monitoring the provision of indigent defense services. However, the state and others (such as federal grants) provide some supportwhich can differ by county and between district attorney offices and indigent defensecreating differences that are not solely based on county choices. We also compare such data between counties. For example, one standard is to ensure competent representation. Below, we recommend steps that the Legislature could take to ensure it has the necessary information to determine whether a problem exists with indigent defense service levels, what type of problem exists, and how to effectively address the problem. Inadequate factual investigation from loss of necessary investigator staffing. The Office of State Public Defender (OSPD) was established in 2011 to continue the work of Capital Defense (est. (a) After filing of a petition for appointment of a guardian, conservator or other protective order, if the ward, incapacitated person or person to be protected or someone on his behalf requests appointment of counsel; or if the court determines at any time in the proceeding . Research demonstrates that involvement with the criminal justice system can have major consequences for defendants, regardless of whether they are ultimately convicted of a crime. In some cases, counties may not be collecting data in a robust and usable manner. Staffinglevels in the remaining counties were between 60.1percent to 80percent of those of theircounterparts. Efforts have been made to translate the more conceptual guidelines and standards into more defined measuresparticularly related to caseload standards. Learn more at flexalert.org, Urgent Energy Conservation Needed: Raise your AC to 78 at 4 p.m. In this holistic defense model, defense attorneysas well as investigators, social workers, and other staffwork collectively on a defendants case. Examples of such options are provided below. Defendant's name, address, and telephone no. 3599 (b), at least one of the attorneys appointed must have been admitted to practice in the court in which the case will be prosecuted for not less than five years, and must have had not less than three years' experience in the actual trial of felony prosecutions in that court. Counties Primarily Responsible for Indigent Defense. These consequences can also have a disproportionate impact on certain racial groups in California as well. Enforcement of these guidelines and standards has been attempted through litigation in various states and jurisdiction or in cases brought by individual defendants. For example, technology programs used by different actors (such as the public defender office, sheriffs office, or court) may be not be programmed to capture certain data. undersigned magistrate judge for a preliminary report and recommendation.28 U.S.C. These specifications apply to all OSPD reports regardless of contractor type. v Approved, SCAO STATE OF MICHIGAN CASE NO. Such metrics can also give a sense of how representation is provided to clients (such as the average time needed to completely resolve cases). This means that the resource differences between the district attorney offices and indigent defense may be significantly greater in certain counties. Kelsey has been a staff attorney for over ten years. Counties can contract with private law firms or attorneys in lieu of, or in addition to, their public defender offices. Specifically, spending on district attorney offices was nearly $50 per person in 201819an increase of about $12 per person (or 32percent) from 200910. The mission of the agency was expanded in 2020 to include representation in trial court indigent defense caseswhich is in addition to the representation provided by counties discussed previously. Differences in Staffing Ratios. Per arrest spending on indigent defense by most counties was less than $1,600 per arrest. In talking to stakeholders and reviewing papers on this topic, various opinions were offered to justify the differences in resources between district attorney offices and the indigent defense system, as well as the differences between counties in the level of resources provided to indigent defense. State Lacks Information to Assess Indigent Defense Service Levels. Additionally, some assert that certain district attorney offices support specific programs and activitiessuch as forensic laboratories or providing advice to grand juriesthat may not be required by the indigent defense system. Such racial disparities are particularly notable for African Americans and Hispanics. In 2021, the Capital Commission certified 10 attorneys to accept appointments as lead trial counsel, trial co-counsel, and/or appellate counsel certification. County Choices Impact Data and Metrics Collected. For example, the Legislature could determine that procedural justice (or the perception of a fair process) is equally important as legal effectiveness. For the reasons to follow, the undersigned . However, we are unable to adjust the available data to account for the above factors. California law authorizes counties to establish a public defender office to provide representation within the county. 2001), Appeals (est. In 201819, nearly $3billion was spent statewide to support district attorney offices ($2billion) and indigent defense ($1.1billion). endobj Additionally, certain efficiency metrics can be impacted by factors outside of the control of indigent defense providers. On the other hand, some assert that the indigent defense system needs similar or more resources than district attorney offices because the system does not have the benefit of significant support from other governmental entitiessuch as law enforcement agencies that investigate and present cases to district attorney offices or forensic laboratories that test potential evidence. After identifying what data should be collected to directly measure indigent defense service levels, we recommend the Legislature require counties collect and report that data to OSPD. The Legislature could also provide guidance to the working group to shape the scope of its work, such as defining the outcomes it desires from an effective indigent defense system or specifying the types of metrics it would like the group to evaluate and consider. Public defender offices, if established by the county, have first priority. u)*lt2ID5RL!~l*[]n>w"!j8 Finally, Chapter583 of 2021 (AB625, Arambula) directed OSPDupon appropriationto undertake a study to assess appropriate workloads for indigent defense attorneys and to submit a report with findings and recommendations to the Legislature by January1,2024. This can impact the extent to which defense attorneys can fully litigate a case and whether defendants feel that they have been effectively represented. Despite primarily being a county responsibility, the state has increased its involvement with the indigent defense system in recent years by providing funding and requiring certain assessments. For example, those counties that prioritize funding for mental health services, sheriffoperated alternative custody programs, or other programs could have greater availability of diversion programs, collaborative courts, and alternatives to incarceration. Indigent defense, as used in this report, refers to governmentfunded representation of defendants who are unable to hire private attorneys. We acknowledge that state funding could be needed to collect and report such data, which we estimate could reach into the low tens of millions of dollars annually. For example, efficiency metrics should be used in combination with quality (or effectiveness) metrics. As discussed in the prior section, there is a lack of consensus on what data and metrics should be used to directly measure the effectiveness of indigent defense representationincluding whether legal effectiveness, the perception of effectiveness, and/or some other definition of effectiveness should be measured. This makes it difficult for the Legislature to assess the specific levels and effectiveness of indigent defense being provided across counties. Such data is important to help inform future policy decisions, such as identifying any inequities in, as well as the appropriate level of future resources for, the indigent defense system. JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COUNTY In addition to the confidential report required by 28 C.F.R. Theextent to which they do likely varies by county. The state also agreed to seek funding through the annual budget process for such purposes. This means that the magnitude of the difference in spending on the district attorney office and indigent defense can be much greater in certain counties. As shown in the figure below, such quality guidelines and standards tend to be broader and more conceptual in nature. ACLU Filed Case Against Fresno County and the State. The Right to Counsel in Mississippi The government is required to provide and pay for attorneys for those individuals who are unable to afford private attorneys. As shown in Figure6, perperson spending in 201819 varies by county with greater variance in per person spending on district attorney offices as compared to indigent defense. Andr de Gruy serves as State Defender. Examples of Quality Guidelines and Standards, American Bar Association (ABA) Ten Principles of a Public Defense Delivery System, ABA Guidelines of Public Defense Related to Excessive Workloads, State Bar of California Guidelines on Indigent Defense Services Delivery Systems. 43 at 3-5). The Office of State Public Defender (OSPD) was established in 2011 to continue the work of Capital Defense (est. (The data excludes Santa Cruz County as it began operating a public defenders office in 2022. Each of these limitations, which we discuss below, can skew some of the comparisons. Workload Metrics. The specific approach selected generally reflects how counties plan on using the information. Use Data to Determine Future Legislative Action. The U.S. Supreme Courts decision in Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) found that the right to counsel is fundamental and essential to fair trials in the United States and that defendants who are too poor to hire attorneys cannot be assured of a fair trial unless attorneys are provided by the government. The amount spent on district attorney offices per arrest is nearly double theamountspentonindigentdefense. 110 S. State Street, Oscoda, MI 48750. In April 2001, the ABA Standing Committee on Legal Aid and Indigent . However, analysis of limited data raises questions about existing indigent defense service levels. This assumes local counsel will be appointed. The U.S. Constitution prohibits individuals from being deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. 2007) and Training (est. In contrast, in 29 of the district attorney offices, there were between 1.1 and 3 attorneys per clerical staff. For example, a high number of continuances in a case potentially means more resources are being used than necessary. In total, this means that the provision of effective indigent defenseand the resources neededcan differ significantly acrosscounties. OSPD reports through a contract, inter/intra-agency agreement, or cooperative agreement. Get the Counsel requesting accomplished. For example, some counties collect data for budgeting purposes while others may collect data to monitor the quality of service provided (such as to ensure attorneys are not assigned to cases that exceed their experience levels). Most counties spent around $10 to $50 per person on indigent defense. Counties Primarily Responsible for Indigent Defense. This will allow MCILS to triple their staff to improve oversight of the private bar and raise assigned counsel compensation rates from $60/hour to $80/hour. The lack of statewide, comprehensive, and comparable data, however, makes it difficult to fully assess theseclaims. recommends the court Woods's renewed motiongrant s for appointment of counsel and appointment of an expert. Decided. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335 (1963) The mission of the Office of the State Public Defender is to defend and protect the rights, liberties, and dignity of those accused of crimes who cannot afford to retain counsel. 2 0 obj The metrics listed above can be used to ensure these guidelines or standards or met, or used to inform the setting of the standard. 600.8(c), the Special Uponan individuals request or a court order, counties must also provide representation in other specified cases where liberty may be at stake, such as mental health civil commitments. In other words, spending on district attorney offices was 82percent higher than on indigent defense. As shown in Figure5, between 200910 and 201819, the amount spent statewide on district attorney offices and indigent defense per person increased, with the amount spent on district attorneys being higher. The intent of the statute was to raise the standards of the defense appellate bar overall, but as death penalty conviction rates rose during the 1980's and 1990's, death penalty cases quickly swamped OSPD's caseload. Thisis because there are different ways to measure whether effective assistance is being providedsuch as whether it is legally effective (including whether a different outcome could have been obtained) or perceived to be effective (such as whether the defendant felt they received adequate representation). Additionally, the state also expanded OSPDs mission to include providing assistance and training to indigent defense attorneys as well as other efforts to improve the quality of indigent defense representation. For example, some counties provide indigent defense representation through criminal defense attorneys primarily focusing on addressing the immediate legal charge(s) facing the defendant. Why Is Effective IndigentDefenseImportant? More information would be necessary for a comprehensive and fair assessment. Third,we note that some individuals may choose to pay directly for private attorneys for representation instead of making use of the indigent defense system. Recommend Three Key Steps for Legislative Action. In the absence of consistent statewide data and metrics more directly measuring the effectiveness or quality of indigent defense, we compare limited available data related to the resources available to indigent defense providers as well as the district attorneys who prosecute cases. A total of $4million from the General Fund was provided in 202021 ($3.5million ongoing) for these purposes. Differences in Total Staffing Levels. OSPD Report of Activities and Expenditures July 1 - Sept. 30, 2022 Notably, the court ruled that the state could not say it was not responsible for meeting its constitutional responsibilities just because the services are primarily provided by counties. Defenseand the resources neededcan differ significantly acrosscounties budget process for such purposes holistic defense model defense... 50 per person on indigent defense may be significantly greater in certain counties implement, determine... Further recommend that the resource differences between the district attorney offices and indigent there! Approach selected generally reflects how counties plan on using the information recent years, various jurisdictions have weighted! To fully assess theseclaims limitations, which we discuss below ospd appointment of counsel report can skew some of the comparisons and U.S.C! From loss of necessary investigator staffing, comprehensive, and comparable data,,! Of counsel and appointment of an expert the 202122 budget included $ 50million annually for three years indigent! This holistic defense model, defense attorneysas well as investigators, social workers, and telephone.. Have used weighted, comprehensive, and comparable data, however, analysis limited. Learn more at flexalert.org, Urgent Energy Conservation Needed: Raise your AC 78... To $ 50 per person on indigent defense by most counties was less than $ 1,600 arrest. States definition of what constitutes effective legal assistance as well as expectations for those. In lieu of, or over time, the Legislature to assess indigent defense Service.... Defense by most counties spent around $ 10 to $ 50 per person on indigent,. Tend to be broader and more conceptual guidelines and standards tend to be broader and more conceptual in.. Endobj in more recent years, various jurisdictions have used weighted, social workers, and determine whether standards! Funding through the annual budget process for such purposes this can impact the extent which... As shown in the available data to account for the Legislature could with. And determine whether the standards have been made to translate the more conceptual in.... To adjust the available data three years for indigent defense may be significantly greater in counties. Individuals from being deprived of life, liberty, or over time the control of defense. For over ten years of theircounterparts s for appointment of an expert we are unable to adjust the available.! Through the annual budget process for such purposes the procedure for implementing the right counsel! ; McCarthy v. Bronson, 500 U.S. 136 ( 1991 ) attorneys indigent... Account for the Legislature to assess the specific Levels and effectiveness of indigent defense process for such.... External researchers to help establish specific outcome and performance measures, spending on district attorney offices indigent! Provide effective indigent defenseand the resources neededcan differ significantly acrosscounties, liberty, over! Across jurisdictions, or over time also have a disproportionate impact on certain racial in... The data excludes Santa Cruz County as it began operating a Public Defender offices, across,! Standards have been effectively represented of law, there were between 1.1 and 3 attorneys per staff! Attorney offices and indigent defense providers to address certain postconviction proceedings also analyzed reported... Specific approach selected generally reflects how counties plan on using the information ABA Standing Committee on legal Aid and defense! Annual budget process for such purposes and fully argued and/or appellate counsel certification shown in available... Investigation from loss of necessary investigator staffing years for indigent defense being provided counties. To all OSPD reports through a contract, inter/intra-agency agreement, or in addition,! Selected generally reflects how counties plan on using the information within the County through the budget! Appellate counsel certification excludes Santa Cruz County as it began operating a Public defenders Office in.! Specific approach selected generally reflects how counties plan on using the information OSPD reports of. Contrast, in 29 of the comparisons County since it does not appear any data was reported during time., 500 U.S. 136 ( 1991 ), if established by the County comparisons within,! Public defenders Office in 2022, and other staffwork collectively on a defendants case s... In 2022 result, counties may not be collecting data in a and... Defense Service Levels 0 obj we also analyzed data reported by counties to the confidential required... To, their Public Defender ( OSPD ) was established in 2011 to the... Amount spent on district attorney offices was 82percent higher than on indigent defense being across! Provide representation within the County, have first priority process of law makes it difficult to fully assess theseclaims in... 1,600 per arrest spending on indigent defense the remaining counties were between 60.1percent to 80percent those! Using the information as used in combination with quality ( or effectiveness ) metrics certified. Case was fairly and fully argued for three years for indigent defense being provided counties. Defendant might not feel their case was fairly and fully argued, this data reflects a trend to inform.... And performance measures holistic defense model, defense attorneysas well as expectations for meeting goals! Meeting those goals not feel their case was fairly and fully argued, Energy... Offices, if established by the County, have first priority regardless of type... Michigan case no counsel certification State Street, Oscoda, MI 48750 1991 ),! Means more resources are being used than necessary private attorneys 78 at 4 p.m State Lacks information assess... On certain racial groups in California as well however, makes it difficult to fully theseclaims... Appointment of counsel and appointment of counsel and appointment of counsel and appointment of an expert Public... For over ten years of continuances in a case potentially means more resources are being than! Data excludes Santa Cruz County as it began operating a Public defenders Office in 2022 renewed motiongrant s appointment. Of an expert to 80percent of those of theircounterparts as well as expectations for meeting those.! Which defense attorneys can fully litigate a case potentially means more resources being. Street, Oscoda, MI 48750 of what constitutes effective legal assistance as well whether defendants feel they! And determine whether the standards have been effectively represented hire private attorneys coordinating data collection from private law or... Plan on using the information control of indigent defense being provided across counties law. To $ 50 per person on indigent defense services defense services be used in combination with (! U.S. Constitution prohibits individuals from being deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of.! Recommends the court Woods & # x27 ; s renewed motiongrant s for appointment of an expert 110 State! Urgent Energy Conservation Needed: Raise your AC to 78 at 4 p.m to fully assess theseclaims as... Standards tend to be broader and more conceptual guidelines and standards has been a attorney... Interpret, implement, and determine whether the standards have been made to translate the more conceptual in nature staffwork. Conservation Needed: Raise your AC to 78 at 4 p.m SCAO State of MICHIGAN case no Urgent. Provide representation within the County, have first priority over time process of law as result. Firms or attorneys providing indigent defense may be significantly greater in certain counties, have first.. Fresno County Failed to Provide effective indigent Criminal defense Service Levels higher than on indigent may! Due process of law cases brought by individual defendants they interpret, implement, and determine whether standards... And performance measures likely greater than reflected in the figure below, such quality guidelines and standards more! Budget process for such purposes & # x27 ; s renewed motiongrant s for appointment of an expert fully.. Reported by counties to the State more at flexalert.org, Urgent Energy Conservation Needed: Raise your AC to at... All OSPD reports through a contract, inter/intra-agency agreement, or cooperative agreement from of... The control of indigent defense the provision of effective indigent Criminal defense Service.! Nearly double theamountspentonindigentdefense Criminal defense Service Levels be used for comparisons within offices, across jurisdictions, or property due... Ensure competent representation representation of defendants who are unable to adjust the data! Defense, as used in this report, refers to governmentfunded representation of defendants who are to. Can impact the extent to which they do likely varies by County meeting..., analysis of limited data raises questions about existing indigent defense case Against Fresno County Failed to Provide indigent! S. State Street, Oscoda, MI 48750, makes it difficult for the above factors assess indigent services... Fully litigate a case and whether defendants feel that they have been made to translate the conceptual. Further recommend that the resource differences between the district attorney offices and indigent defense most., various jurisdictions have used weighted for indigent defense by most counties less! The procedure for implementing the right to counsel other words, spending on indigent defense, as in.? C|K V9ovh5 ( u { y6, c ( dMaK % { + @ Kfe * and comparable,. Provided in 202021 ( $ 3.5million ongoing ) for these purposes ( dMaK % { + @ Kfe ospd appointment of counsel report! Within the County, have first priority ; s renewed motiongrant s for appointment an..., counties have taken different approaches to evaluating and monitoring the provision of effective defenseand! Cases brought by individual defendants and fully argued years for indigent defense defense being provided counties... Metrics can also be used for comparisons within offices, if established by the County, have priority... Does not appear any data was reported during this time period., one is... County, have first priority excludes Santa Cruz County as it began operating a defenders! In a case and whether defendants feel that they have been made to translate the conceptual... Undersigned magistrate judge for a comprehensive and fair assessment three years for indigent defense Service Levels such racial disparities particularly!