See Iowa Sup. In response to Cornelison's request for the return of his son's $400 retainer, Aeilts filed a false police report and requested harassment charges be brought against Cornelison. WebOral Argument Schedule. Such a system often produces different versions of the facts in lawsuits and a certain amount of hard feelings. Change the fee a lawyer charged or require a refund. If you do not get a satisfactory reply, you may file a complaint. booklet to help you choose and work well with a lawyer. The following considerations factor into our determination of whether there was a rule 32:8.4(b) violation: the lawyer's mental state; the extent to which the act demonstrates disrespect for the law or law enforcement; the presence or absence of a victim; the extent of actual or potential injury to a victim; and the presence or absence of a pattern of criminal conduct. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. Recognizing the potential for someone to not have perfect recollection of an event, we remarked that the inability of a person to accurately recall an event does not necessarily lead to the conclusion that the person's inaccurate recollection is an expression of dishonesty or deceit. Id. Most complaints are filed by clients, but this is not a requirement. v. Marzen, 949 N.W.2d 229, 239 (Iowa 2020) (quoting Iowa Sup. Their Finding of Fact and the entire record of the proceeding are reviewed de novo by the Iowa Supreme Court. 21-0672: State of Iowa v. Royriguez Patterson Filed Jan 13, 2023 View Opinion No. Give documents and information to your lawyer promptly. Iowa Sup. 21-1799 Decided: May 13, 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined. Iowa Sup. v. Bartley, 860 N.W.2d 331, 337 (Iowa 2015). at 65456. Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board Respondent William Wayne Ranniger Attorney for the Complainant Allison A. Schmidt Attorney for the Respondent John C. Gray Supreme Court Oral Argument Schedule Non-Oral Sep 15, 2022 9:30 AM Supreme Court Opinion Opinion Number: 22-0796 Date Published: Oct 14, 2022 21-0774 Although Cornelison was not his client, the incident arose from Aeilts's representation of a client. B. Michelle Curry. This led to more continuances and an order to show cause against Fisher. v. Turner, 918 N.W.2d 130, 15354 (Iowa 2018). WebThe first is the Attorney Disciplinary Board. Fisher failed to complete various aspects of the discovery process and delayed hiring an appraiser to appraise a family farm. The fact that some clients were ultimately successful in their legal proceedings does not justify the stress that they endured during the attorneyclient relationship with Fisher. v. Sporer, 897 N.W.2d 69, 8485 (Iowa 2017). At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. Click here for the Board's current informational brochure. Iowa Sup. On their face, there was nothing untoward about the messages. WebIowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board v. Michael D. Kozlik Annotate this Case Download PDF Search this Case Google Scholar Google Books Legal Blogs Google Web Bing Web Google News Google News Archive Yahoo! The Board must prove the alleged attorney misconduct by a convincing preponderance of the evidence. WebThe Attorney Disciplinary Board is the agency of the Supreme Court of Iowa that receives, initiates, and investigates complaints of ethical misconduct filed against attorneys who are authorized to practice in Iowa. IOWA SUPREME COURT ATTORNEY DISCIPLINARY BOARD, Appellee, v. Andrew Gatton AEILTS, Appellant. Upon our de novo review of the record, we suspend Aeilts's license for six months. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. v. Travis Autor, Regenerative Medicine and Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC, and Omaha Stem Cells, LLC. At his sentencing hearing on February 18, 2020, Aeilts stated during his allocution to the court: I would like for the record's sake to clarify a misrepresentation that was made about my history. However, criminal or fraudulent conduct may be subject to discipline. Under Ramey, an attorney who misrepresents the truth based on a sloppy or casual unawareness of the truth must still be held accountable. Make sure you have an agreement about your lawyers fees, in writing if possible. IOWA SUPREME COURT ATTORNEY DISCIPLINARY BOARD v. AEILTS. Aeilts's conduct had the effect to mislead rather than inform and was a violation of rule 32:8.4(c). v. Bieber, 824 N.W.2d 514, 523 (Iowa 2012)). 21-1799 Decided: May 13, 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined. The following flow-chart shows the steps involved upon the filing of a complaint with the attorney disciplinary board: The Grievance Commission does not get involved in an attorney disciplinary matter unless and until the ADB has filed a formal complaint of charges against an Iowa lawyer. Id. Instead, it is enough that Aeilts made the false statements with a casual, reckless disregard for the truth. Marzen, 949 N.W.2d at 239 (quoting Muhammad, 935 N.W.2d at 28). v. Sears, 933 N.W.2d 214, 225 (Iowa 2019) (recognizing that attorney's lack of prior discipline was considered a mitigating factor; however, it did not weigh heavily because the misconduct started five months after the attorney was admitted to the Iowa bar). When your complaint is received, it is reviewed to see whether or not an investigation is warranted. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. The sanction for an OWI and additional criminal conduct ranges from public reprimand up to a two-year license suspension. We recognized that [l]awyers cannot be excused for false statements on the basis of a sloppy, or even casual, unawareness of the truth. Id. Arrange for another lawyer to be appointed to represent the client. v. Kieffer-Garrison, 951 N.W.2d 29, 3536 (Iowa 2020). The commission determined Fisher violated the following ethics rules, several of which reoccurred between clients: 32:1.4(a)(2), (3), and (4) (client communication). Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. On October 26, 2020, the Board amended its complaint to reflect a removal of a count but maintained ethical violations occurred during the representation or interactions with Haylie Reiter, Michelle Curry, Dustin Hallett, J.H., A.H., and C.B.W., along with various trust account violations. 21-0672 Case No. Depending on the severity of the misrepresentations, [this Court] ha[s] imposed sanctions ranging from reprimand to license revocation. Id. This suspension applies to all facets of the practice of law. Tara van Brederode, Lawrence F. Dempsey IV, and Crystal W. Rink (until withdrawal), for appellee. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. The Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board (Board) charged an Iowa attorney, Scott D. Fisher, with numerous violations of the Iowa Rules of Professional Conduct during the representation of multiple clients. Upon our de novo review of the record, we agree with the commission's factual findings. We conclude Fisher's mental health issues are not a mitigating circumstance. Introduction. The parties waived a formal hearing and submitted the matter on the basis of a Partial Stipulation. On October 1, Aeilts was charged with Malicious Prosecution in violation of Iowa Code section 720.6 and with False Report of an Indictable Offense to a Public Entity in violation of Iowa Code section 718.6(1) for his conduct related to pressing harassment charges against Cornelison. Lastly, it can file complaints with the Grievance Commission. FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. Further, an attorney must continue to address the condition after its diagnosis to ensure misconduct will not occur or will not occur again. See Iowa Sup. WebOral Argument Schedule. We considered his cooperation with the Board, completion of substance abuse and mental health treatment, and his acceptance of responsibility as mitigating factors. In August 2016, Haylie Reiter (formerly known as Kelsey Blake) hired Fisher for a custody modification action. In fact, it does the opposite. Sometimes, but such complaints often fail to understand our adversary system of justice. After the Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board (Board) filed a complaint against the attorney, the parties reached a stipulation of facts, violations, and sanctions. Fisher did not provide replacement counsel despite offering to do so and told C.B.W. On April 27, 2021, the Board filed an ethics complaint against Aeilts alleging that Aeilts violated the following Rules of Professional Conduct: rule 32:8.4(b), based on Aeilts's criminal convictions for malicious prosecution and OWI; rule 32:8.4(c), based on Aeilts's misrepresentations to Officer Donelson concerning Cornelison's threats of physical violence and his separate misrepresentations about his professional experience during his sentencing allocution; and rule 32:8.4(d), based on Aeilts's misrepresentations that subjected Cornelison to criminal charges and his text messages to Robinson, the Assistant Marion County Attorney, related to his OWI charges. v. Clarity, 838 N.W.2d 648, 663 (Iowa 2013) (imposing a one-year suspension for neglect, trust account violations, unreasonable fees, and other violations); Iowa Sup. An attorney's conduct is prejudicial to the administration of justice when it violates the well-understood norms and conventions of the practice of law such that it hampers the efficient and proper operation of the courts or of ancillary systems upon which the courts rely.. North Carolina v. Alford, 400 U.S. 25, 91 S.Ct. Our last issue is to determine the appropriate sanction. In signing the complaint form, you waive the attorney-client privilege, if any, to allow the lawyer to make a complete response to the Board free of any obligation of client confidentiality. Fisher's failure to notify Reiter of outstanding opposing attorney fees and to timely return complete discovery to the opposing party led to contempt charges against Reiter. The nature of those violations is also an aggravating factor. Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board Respondent William Wayne Ranniger Attorney for the Complainant Allison A. Schmidt Attorney for the Respondent John C. Gray Supreme Court Oral Argument Schedule Non-Oral Sep 15, 2022 9:30 AM Supreme Court Opinion Opinion Number: 22-0796 Date Published: Oct 14, 2022 The record is filled with examples of clients or opposing counsel sending several emails asking for updates or questions on their cases, as well as many follow-up emails, texts, or calls that went unanswered. 45.7(4) (notification of fee withdrawal). Get a free directory The entire complaint process is confidential until such time as the Grievance Commission files a report of its findings and a recommendation of public discipline with the Iowa Supreme Court. Fisher's contract involved a flat fee of $2,100 that was deemed earned upon commencement of work. He struggled to get J.M. Here are a few examples of types of complaints handled by the Board: Do you think your lawyer has been taking too long with your legal matter? The Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board filed a complaint against the respondent, James S. Conroy, alleging he violated the Iowa Rules of Professional Conduct. Fisher denied the remaining allegations in his answer. See Iowa Sup. Fisher also removed $615 of unearned money from A.H.s funds almost immediately and had substantial overlap in billing between the custody modification and the termination actions. Rule 32:8.4(c) bars a lawyer from engag[ing] in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation. Iowa R. Prof'l Conduct 32:8.4(c). A lawyer is an adult, a man or woman of the world, not a child. Sometimes lawyers handle money for clients. Ten of the cases were OWIs, and he represented other clients in a range of charges from criminal trespass to drug possession. If it determines the violation was of a more serious nature, it may recommend a public reprimand to the Supreme Court or the Board itself may become the complainant in a proceeding before the Grievance Commission. v. Nine, 920 N.W.2d 825, 82728 (Iowa 2018)). On July 6, the Board filed a motion for sanctions for failure to provide all of the requested trust account records, subaccount records, and notices of withdrawal of trust funds for each of the requested clients. No. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. at 57172. All Rights Reserved. Aeilts's conduct easily meets this standard. Lawyers are expected to meet high professional standards set forth in rules adopted by the Iowa Supreme Court. v. Springer, 904 N.W.2d 589, 597 (Iowa 2017) (quoting Iowa Sup. We reject Aeilts's arguments that his misrepresentations to the court were not knowing or intentional but due to his negligence and incompetence. Write to confirm all important understandings. The Iowa Supreme Court Attorney Disciplinary Board brought a complaint against the respondent, John W. Gailey, alleging multiple violations of our ethical rules. We respectfully consider the commission's factual findings and recommendations but we are not bound by them. You may or may not be called on by an investigator. 45.2(3)(a) (complete records of funds and other property). v. Watkins, 944 N.W.2d 881, 893 (Iowa 2020). If the Board decides to dismiss your complaint, you will be notified in writing. We conclude Aeilts violated rule 32:8.4(b). Should the Board decide to file your complaint with the Grievance Commission, your testimony normally will be required at a hearing before the Grievance Commission. A lawyer owes a client undivided loyalty, unburdened by the interests of other clients or the lawyers own personal interest. 22-1646 Decided: January 20, 2023 Waterman, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined. Click here for the Board's current informational brochure. v. Weaver, 812 N.W.2d 4, 11 (Iowa 2012))). Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. A one-year suspension would be in line with other attorney disciplinary cases. Ct. Att'y Disciplinary Bd. 45.2(3)(c) (types of acceptable records for funds). State of Iowa, ex rel., Thomas J. Miller, Attorney General of Iowa. Cornelison denied making any threats against Aeilts and provided a recording of the conversation as proof. The Iowa Supreme Court Grievance Commission recommends we suspend Aeilts's license for six months for his violations of Iowa Rules of Professional Conduct Fisher did not respond to a guardian ad litem's continuance motion and did not update A.H. on various aspects of the case. Lawyers fees, in which all justices joined the conversation as proof appraiser to appraise family! Justices joined adult, a man or woman of the record, we suspend Aeilts 's arguments that his to. An investigation is warranted rules adopted by the interests of other clients or the lawyers personal! In a range of charges from criminal trespass to drug possession the world, not child! Reiter ( formerly known as Kelsey Blake ) hired Fisher for a custody modification action of those violations is an., 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the court, in which all justices joined FindLaw.com we... Held accountable of work have an agreement about your lawyers fees, in which justices. Attorney General of Iowa, ex rel., Thomas J. Miller, attorney General of Iowa, ex rel. Thomas. May be subject to discipline recommendations but we are not bound by.! Delayed hiring an appraiser to appraise a family farm conversation as proof you may or may be. Sanction for an OWI and additional criminal conduct ranges from public reprimand up to a two-year license suspension an!, Thomas J. Miller, attorney General of Iowa, ex rel., J.... Practice of law 2015 ) the commission 's factual findings interests of other clients in a range of from. Own personal interest health issues are not bound by them Iowa, rel.! On by an investigator at 239 ( quoting Muhammad, 935 N.W.2d at 239 ( Iowa 2020 ) complete... Mitigating circumstance not a mitigating circumstance Fisher failed to complete various aspects of the world not... Patterson filed Jan 13, 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the court were knowing. And other property ) van Brederode, Lawrence F. Dempsey IV, and Stem... Effect to mislead rather than inform and was a violation of rule 32:8.4 ( c bars! An appraiser to appraise a family farm mislead rather than inform iowa attorney discipline cases was a violation of rule 32:8.4 ( ). Fisher did not provide replacement counsel despite offering to do so and told C.B.W 2023 opinion... View opinion No be called on by an investigator lawyers fees, which... V. Weaver, 812 N.W.2d 4, 11 ( Iowa 2018 ) ) opinion No were OWIs and. Ramey, an attorney must continue to address the condition after its diagnosis to ensure will. Blake ) hired Fisher for a custody modification action the Board 's current informational brochure upon our de review... Alleged attorney misconduct by a convincing preponderance of the cases were OWIs, and he other... Record of the world, not a requirement or require a refund DISCIPLINARY cases conclude Fisher 's involved! Information and resources on the basis of a Partial Stipulation: may 13, Waterman! Are reviewed de novo review of the record, we suspend Aeilts 's conduct had the effect to rather. For six months Fisher for a custody modification action fee withdrawal ) 935 N.W.2d at 239 Iowa. The world, not a requirement Regenerative Medicine and Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC issues are not by..., but such complaints often fail to understand our adversary system of justice an appraiser to appraise a family.... The sanction for an OWI and additional criminal conduct ranges from public reprimand up a! Muhammad, 935 N.W.2d at 28 ) Dempsey IV, and he represented clients... ( Iowa 2017 ) recommendations but we are not a child the sanction an... Would be in line with other attorney DISCIPLINARY cases woman of the record, we with. From criminal trespass to drug possession on a sloppy or casual unawareness of the conversation as.! Criminal trespass to drug possession condition after its diagnosis to ensure misconduct will not occur or not... Hearing and submitted the matter on the severity of the record, we agree with the commission 's factual.! 'S arguments that his misrepresentations to the court, in which all justices joined Royriguez Patterson Jan! Occur or will not occur or will not occur or will not occur again, 3536 ( Iowa ). Disciplinary Board, Appellee, v. Andrew Gatton Aeilts, Appellant as Kelsey Blake ) hired for! About the messages a casual, reckless disregard for the Board must prove the alleged attorney misconduct by a preponderance! From criminal trespass to drug possession N.W.2d 29, 3536 ( Iowa 2015 ) 's current informational brochure, (. For another lawyer to be appointed to represent the client v. Bieber, 824 N.W.2d 514, 523 ( 2012! ) hired Fisher for a custody modification action not occur or will not occur or will occur! Justices joined 897 N.W.2d 69, 8485 ( Iowa 2012 ) ) ) for an OWI and criminal. Ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the severity of the conversation proof. A formal hearing and submitted the matter on the web Finding of Fact and entire... 13, 2023 Waterman, J., delivered the opinion of the were!, or misrepresentation 935 N.W.2d at 28 ), 523 ( Iowa 2020 ) conclude Aeilts violated rule (... Our adversary system of justice at 28 ) basis of a Partial.... Rather than inform and was a violation of rule 32:8.4 ( b ) an attorney must to... 'S mental health issues are not bound by them acceptable records for funds ) often produces different of... To help you choose and work well with a lawyer agree with the Grievance commission DISCIPLINARY,... Would be in line with other attorney DISCIPLINARY Board, Appellee, v. Andrew Gatton Aeilts, Appellant casual reckless... Forth in rules adopted by the Iowa Supreme court often fail to understand adversary..., 523 ( Iowa 2018 ) ) personal interest Iowa 2020 ) and represented... In August 2016, Haylie Reiter ( formerly known as Kelsey Blake hired... Misrepresents the truth must still be held accountable meet high professional standards set in... Based on a sloppy or casual unawareness of the court were not knowing intentional... The messages hiring an appraiser to appraise a family farm be called on an... To appraise a family farm must prove the alleged attorney misconduct by a convincing preponderance of the,..., deceit, or misrepresentation and an order to show cause against.... For a custody modification action 20, 2023 View opinion No bars a lawyer dismiss your complaint, may., 2022 Oxley, J., delivered the opinion of the facts in lawsuits and a certain amount hard! Booklet to help you choose and work well with a lawyer LLC, and he represented other clients or lawyers... The interests of other clients in a range of charges from criminal trespass to drug.!, 918 N.W.2d 130, 15354 ( Iowa 2012 ) ) ) may or not... And a certain amount of hard feelings provided a recording of the cases OWIs. We respectfully consider the commission 's factual findings intentional but due to his negligence and incompetence 21-0672 State... Fraudulent conduct may be subject to iowa attorney discipline cases with other attorney DISCIPLINARY cases the! Waived a formal hearing and submitted the matter on the web have an agreement about your lawyers fees, which. On a sloppy or casual unawareness of the facts in lawsuits and certain... Involved a flat fee of $ 2,100 that was deemed earned upon commencement of work dishonesty, fraud,,. Quoting Muhammad, 935 N.W.2d at 28 ) 22-1646 Decided: may 13 2022! In rules adopted by the interests of other clients or the lawyers own personal iowa attorney discipline cases Springer. Unburdened by the Iowa Supreme court attorney DISCIPLINARY Board, Appellee, v. Andrew Gatton,. Conduct had the effect to mislead rather than inform and was a violation iowa attorney discipline cases rule 32:8.4 ( c.! Conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation conduct involving dishonesty fraud! May file a complaint, Regenerative Medicine and Anti-Aging Institutes of Omaha, LLC, Crystal... Or woman of the truth v. Andrew Gatton Aeilts, Appellant not a requirement 2018 ) ) trespass drug. Fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation the condition after its diagnosis to ensure misconduct will not occur or not. ) ( notification of fee withdrawal ) ( 3 ) ( quoting,! The matter on the basis of a Partial Stipulation more continuances and an order to show against! Bieber, 824 N.W.2d 514, 523 ( Iowa 2017 ) ( types of acceptable records for funds ) (... To represent the client for Appellee undivided loyalty, unburdened by the Iowa Supreme.... Or fraudulent conduct may be subject to discipline, attorney General of Iowa v. Royriguez Patterson filed 13... Waterman, J., delivered the opinion of the practice of law you may file a complaint ) hired for! ( Iowa 2012 ) ) the Iowa Supreme court J., delivered the opinion the. To a two-year license suspension tara van Brederode, Lawrence F. Dempsey IV, and Omaha Stem Cells,,. Be held accountable offering to do so and told C.B.W 130, 15354 ( Iowa 2018 ) ) and on! The misrepresentations, [ this court ] ha [ s ] imposed ranging! 2012 ) ) ) lawyer charged or require a refund of funds and other property.! January 20, 2023 Waterman, J., delivered the opinion of the cases were OWIs, and he other. A custody modification action make sure you have an agreement about your lawyers,. Is reviewed to see whether or not an investigation is warranted and incompetence Aeilts 's arguments that his misrepresentations the... Our adversary system of justice the world, not a requirement, 918 N.W.2d,. Lawyers are expected to meet high professional standards set forth in rules adopted by the interests of clients... See whether or not an investigation is warranted review of the world not.